HomeClasses and AppearancesContact UsOne to One with ElizabethMember Area
Baking and Cooking Tips
All Recipes
Breads, Quick
Breads, Yeast
Breakfast Recipes Brownies/Bar Recipes
Cake Recipes
Cookie Recipes
Cracker Recipes
Dessert Recipes
Free Recipes!
Holiday Cookie Recipes
Holiday Recipes
Main Course Recipes
Pasta Recipe
Pie Recipes
Side Dish Recipes
Snack Recipes
Soup Recipes

Home | Cookies (Free Recipes) | Copycat Recipe: Gluten-Free Fig Newt . . .

Copycat Recipe: Gluten-Free Fig Newtons

Elizabeth Barbone - May 30, 2014
Printer-Friendly Format

Social media is weird. The other day a photo of Fig Newtons, of all things, came across my Facebook feed. A friend captioned it with, My snack says I'm turning into my grandmother! Looking at that photo, I realized that I missed Fig Newtons. The craving caught me a little by surprise because I hadn't really thought about them since switching to a gluten-free diet. Suddenly enticed, I thought I'd enjoy making my own gluten-free batch.

Honestly, they turned out to be rather tough to replicate.

My first attempt was dreadful. The outer cookie, made of a simple mixture of gluten-free flours and butter, came out like pie crust. It was really flaky instead of tender and cakey.

The filling, which I cooked for several hours, tasted bland. It boggled my mind that a filling made from flavorful figs could be so dull and mild! Yet this filling, made from chopped mission figs, water, and brown sugar, was just that.

Clearly I needed to rethink the entire recipe.

First up: the cookie. Since Fig Newtons are cakey, I added eggs to the dough, along with a little leavening, which my first batch didn't contain. For the filling, I went in the opposite direction by not cooking it at all—I simply puréed dried mission figs with a little water and corn syrup.

The second batch turned out much closer to the real deal, but it was still a little off. The cookie felt too fatty and while filling tasted sweet, it still had no real depth.

To address these problems, I reduced the amount of butter in the cookie and replaced half the granulated sugar with dark brown sugar to boost the flavor and add some moisture. I also added a little orange oil, since I remembered Fig Newtons having a subtle citrus note. For the filling, I again puréed the dried figs, but this time I added freshly squeezed lemon juice and a little salt.

The cookie baked beautifully, while the lemon juice and salt boosted the flavor of the filling without competing with the figs. But there was still one problem: the outer cookie tasted too buttery.

Commercial Fig Newtons don't taste like butter, so for the final batch, I used shortening instead of butter. That simple swap made a big difference. At long last, the cookies tasted just like the Fig Newtons I remembered.

And even though I finally perfected the recipe, I still needed to wait before enjoying them, since both the flavor and texture improve after an overnight rest. Following a technique from Bravetart's homemade fig newton recipe, I transferred the warm cookies into a sealed container, allowing them to steam slightly. After all that work, I wondered if the fig newtons were worth it. Then I bit into one and got my answer: in this case, there's nothing better than turning into your grandmother.

About the author: Elizabeth Barbone is the owner and editor of and is the author of Easy Gluten-Free Baking. and "How to Cook Gluten-Free".

comments powered by Disqus

Printer-Friendly Format